ao link
Farmers Guardian
News
Over The Farm Gate

Over The Farm Gate

This Is Agriculture - Sponsored

This Is Agriculture - Sponsored

DataHub

DataHub

Auction Finder

Auction Finder

British Farming Awards

British Farming Awards

The Mart's the Heart

The Mart's the Heart

CropTec

CropTec

Farming matters: Abi Reader – ‘CHeCS is an important tool for breeders, but everyone needs to trust it’

Changes in Johne’s disease testing rules were announced by CHeCs, the body which sets industry standards for cattle disease control across the UK and Ireland, in April.  

Abi Reader - Dairy farmer from Cardiff who sits on the NFU Cymru milk board.
Abi Reader - Dairy farmer from Cardiff who sits on the NFU Cymru milk board.

Some of you may know I chair CHeCS, which has set standards for cattle disease control in the UK and Ireland for over 20 years.

 

In April, the CHeCS board made a tough decision.


For three years, there have been differences of opinion between CHeCS health schemes about testing for Johne’s disease. Johne’s is difficult. You can’t eradicate it, and it causes progressive wasting and huge losses. It has also been linked to Crohn’s disease in humans so must be dealt with robustly.

I’m not going to get technical; the important bit is the blood test which is designed to detect antibodies for the MAP bacteria that cause Johne’s disease. This can have up to 2 per cent false positive results (or 2 in 100 animals).

Some health schemes cross check positive results with confirmatory dung tests, some don’t, and some do sometimes.

 

A dung test doesn’t clear the animal for breeding but does for calculating overall herd risk level.

 

However, the dung test looks for actual shedding of disease, a stage on from infection. The dung test also has a high incidence of false negative results meaning there is a far greater chance of ‘clearing’ an infected animal than the blood test has of falsely accusing it.


Read More

Breeders raise concerns over new Johne’s testing rulesBreeders raise concerns over new Johne’s testing rules
CHeCS announces changes in Johne’s disease testing rulesCHeCS announces changes in Johne’s disease testing rules

CHeCS announced changes in Johne’s disease testing rules in April.
CHeCS announced changes in Johne’s disease testing rules in April.

Consequences

 

If this seems petty, think about the consequences - two herds with the same rate of infection could be given different risk levels just because one had a false negative dung test.

 

There is trading, financial, health and reputational consequences. So last month the CHeCS board stepped in to rule that follow-up testing will only be allowed in low risk herds – those with 2 per cent (or one animal) positive blood tests or fewer.

There has been quite an outcry.

 

Breeders are understandably concerned their herds will jump risk levels, with questions around what this will mean for their sales and their reputation.

 

However, as one health scheme pointed out, inconsistent application of the rule has been a problem and this change affects everyone.

CHeCS is an important tool for breeders, but everyone needs to trust it.

 

With Johne’s disease now reportable in the EU, the UK must improve its reputation for control. We must also think about the losses and waste we suffer from cattle disease generally, the extra greenhouse gas emissions, the reduced productivity and profitability and the risk of zoonosis.

This change may be painful in the short term, but the bigger picture is critical.

Facebook
Twitter
RSS
Facebook
Twitter
RSS