Farmers Guradian
Topics
How to spot BSE and what farmers can do to prevent it

How to spot BSE and what farmers can do to prevent it

DataHub

DataHub

Dairy Farmer Magazine

Dairy Farmer Magazine

Auction Finder

Auction Finder

CropTec

CropTec

LAMMA 2019

LAMMA 2019

You are viewing your 1 free article

Register now to receive 2 free articles every 7 days or subscribe for unlimited access.

Subscribe | Register

Academics and farming groups clash over suggestions of tax on red meat

Academics and farming groups have clashed over suggestions a tax on red meat should be introduced to account for the ‘cost burden’ on the NHS and spur changes in consumption patterns.


Olivia   Midgley

TwitterFacebook
Olivia   Midgley
TwitterFacebook
A study by the Oxford Martin School and the Nuffield Department of Population Health said a tax, similar to that imposed on alcohol, tobacco and sugar, could prevent almost 6,000 deaths a year in the UK and save the economy more than £700 million in avoided healthcare costs.

 

Main author and vegan Marco Springmann and researchers referred to a controversial World Health Organisation report which linked beef, lamb and pork to an increased risk of heart disease, stroke, diabetes and cancer.   But Dr Carrie Ruxton public health nutritionist and dietitian at the Meat Advisory Panel, said meat consumption had declined significantly, with average intakes now ‘well below’ NHS guidelines.


Read More

Increased consumption of quality red meat will help UK reduce impact on environment Increased consumption of quality red meat will help UK reduce impact on environment
Industry experts blast meat tax petition as 'ridiculous' Industry experts blast meat tax petition as 'ridiculous'
Meat tax ‘increasingly probable’ to keep within 2degc Paris agreement Meat tax ‘increasingly probable’ to keep within 2degc Paris agreement

"There is no high-quality evidence linking red and processed meat with heart disease, stroke or diabetes, and a risk of bowel cancer only applies when weekly intakes exceed 700g. As few people in the UK are at this level of consumption, a general meat tax would be like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut,” said Dr Ruxton.

 

"Chronic disease prevention would be far more effective if it focused on smoking, excess drinking, and bodyweight rather than a single food source like meat, which brings many nutritional benefits such as iron, zinc, vitamin D and B vitamins."

 

Because these nutrients were often in short supply in lower income households, a tax on red meat would be a ‘retrograde step’, she added.

Quality Meat Scotland chairwoman Kate Rowell said studies showed vegetarians and meat eaters had similar rates of colorectal cancer and breast cancer.

 

“Studies do not often address variables such as alcohol consumption, smoking status, obesity and the consumption of fewer vegetables and fibre,” she said.

 

Nuffield scholar and Gloucestershire beef and sheep farmer Geraint Powell warned against sensationalist messaging. 

 

He said: "There are so many scientific papers published, all with polarised views and no balance. People need to be aware of why someone is telling us something as well as what they are telling us."  

  The Scottish Association of Meat Wholesalers added: "Any report which appears to condemn the production of one form of protein on health or environmental grounds without addressing the production systems and processes used for all other protein sources, is surely flawed and in need of more careful preparation."  

TwitterFacebook
Post a Comment
To see comments and join in the conversation please log in.

Most Recent

Facebook
Twitter
RSS
Facebook
Twitter
RSS