Farmers Guradian
Topics
How to spot BSE and what farmers can do to prevent it

How to spot BSE and what farmers can do to prevent it

DataHub

DataHub

Dairy Farmer Magazine

Dairy Farmer Magazine

Auction Finder

Auction Finder

CropTec

CropTec

LAMMA 2019

LAMMA 2019

You are viewing your 1 free article

Register now to receive 2 free articles every 7 days or subscribe for unlimited access.

Subscribe | Register

Labour minister dressed down over anti badger cull stance

Shadow Farming Minister David Drew was slapped down for suggesting badger vaccination alone would eradicate bovine TB (bTB).


Olivia   Midgley

TwitterFacebook
Olivia   Midgley
TwitterFacebook
Share This

Labour minister dressed down over anti badger cull stance #TBFree

Gloucestershire farmer David Barton and deputy NFU president Minette Batters used the conference floor to press the Stroud MP on Labour’s opposition to the badger cull – reaffirmed in its strategy on animal welfare last week – pointing out the recent Brunton (et al) paper, a peer reviewed study which showed badger culling in Gloucestershire and Somerset reduced incidence of bTB in cattle.

 

Mr Drew told delegates he believed a badger vaccination scheme would eventually eradicate bTB and that Labour would ‘follow the science’.

 

Later when asked by Farmers Guardian if he had read the Brunton report, Mr Drew said he had, but it was ‘just one paper’.

 

“I take my evidence from people who I accept are largely opposed to the badger cull, but what I am looking for is conclusive evidence the cull is working,” said Mr Drew.

 

“We will see this as an ongoing disagreement. We will support a vaccination strategy sooner rather than later.”

 

Outgoing president Meurig Raymond said Labour had a ’blind spot’ when it came to bTB.


Read More

Brian May: 'How could the views of a rock star on bTB be worth squat?' Brian May: 'How could the views of a rock star on bTB be worth squat?'
Defra to review 25-year strategy on bovine TB Defra to review 25-year strategy on bovine TB
Special investigation into bTB: More to do in battle against disease Special investigation into bTB: More to do in battle against disease
What next for bovine TB in the Republic of Ireland? What next for bovine TB in the Republic of Ireland?

It came as Defra announced it would conduct a review of its 25-year bTB strategy to consider what additional actions might be needed to get on top of the disease and when they might be deployed.

 

Industry chiefs have been pushing for badger culling in England to be extended to new areas in the next two years.

 

Defra Secretary Michael Gove told the conference Defra was committed to ‘following the science in order to ensure we deal with the disease’.

 

He said: “Bovine TB is a threat to animal welfare. It is a disease which is a threat to the animal population which should be front and centre of any disease eradication strategy.

 

“Now, we know there has been controversy over aspects of the approach this Government has taken on bovine TB and my whole approach is to be guided by the science.

 

“What we want to do is to progressively reduce and eliminate this disease in a way that all animals can be better protected from infection, and we continue to keep under review the best means of doing so, and the right thing to do is say ‘what does the science tell us about how we can prevent this disease spreading and prevent more animals and farm businesses suffering as a result’."

 

When asked if he was committed to the badger cull, he responded: “I am committed to following the science in order to ensure we have the best method possible of containing this disease, but I think as George Eustice pointed out, none of us want to actively engage in any particular method because we have an attachment to a particular method – we follow the science in order to ensure we deal with the disease.”

TwitterFacebook
Post a Comment
To see comments and join in the conversation please log in.

Most Recent

Facebook
Twitter
RSS
Facebook
Twitter
RSS