FG BUY&SELL        FARMERS WEATHER       ARABLE FARMING        DAIRY FARMER      FARMERS GUARDIAN        AGRIMONEY        OUR EVENTS        MEMBERSHIP BENEFITS        BLOGS        MORE FROM US
You are here: News > Insights
Search

You are viewing 1 of your 2 free articles

You’ll need to join us by becoming a member to gain more access.
Already a Member?

Login Join us now

Verdict: Compact telehandler group comparison test

Despite having almost identical spec on paper, it was interesting to see just how much these four compact telehandlers differed.

As we found, there is a lot of compromise in the design of compact telehandlers, especially in terms of component selection, position and layout.

Impressively, we found a telehandler of this size to be a lot more capable than we thought, able to handle a variety of tasks with ease. In many respects, they could certainly be considered an upgrade from a tractor and loader combination.

Twitter Facebook

Dieci Mini Agri 25.6 summary

Dieci Mini Agri 25.6 summary

Highlights of the Mini Agri 25.6 include its simplicity, particularly its transmission operation and un-cluttered cab layout. Like the Merlo, it is quite an amateur-friendly machine to operate and very jump on and drive.

 

On the downside, its poor rear right quarter visibility is hard to ignore and it could do with some livelier hydraulics to give the others a run for their money.

 

However, at a ten grand cheaper retail price than the JCB and Manitou, could you afford to put up with a few inconveniences?

JCB 525-60 Agri Plus Loadall summary

JCB 525-60 Agri Plus Loadall summary

With a telehandler manufacturing heritage such as JCB’s, the 525-50 does have a lot to live up to.

 

Impressively, it looks like the manufacturer has done its homework and combined a lot of favourable elements such as decent cab space, swift hydraulics, good stability, low boom position and good all-round visibility.

 

Some compromising design elements we do not like is the automatic bucket shake function and the reduced steering lock, especially when compared to the others.

Manitou MLT 625-75H Premium summary

Manitou MLT 625-75H Premium summary

The 625 is clearly a well thought out machine. Practical and modern, its design is very smart. Despite its ‘compact’ stature, it brings with it many features found on its larger siblings. 

 

Highlights include its auto handbrake function which automatically ‘holds’ the 625 with foot lifted off the throttle and allows the driver to operate boom functions in comfort. Once used to it, the JSM joystick is an absolute peach, putting all primary controls to hand.

 

Transmission was well refined with good control characteristics, but we feel the low range’s top speed should be set higher. Visibility is not as good to the blind side as the JCB or Merlo – a design compromise we can forgive.

Merlo Panoramic P25.6 summary

Merlo Panoramic P25.6 summary

Yes it looks a little dated and industrial looking but as a predominantly mechanical telehandler with great visibility it will be very attractive to many customers.

 

Loader control is good thanks to a direct connection to the loader’s valve chest - faster boom hydraulics would be nice though.

 

The transmission is pretty much all mechanical and one of the simplest to operate with a good amount of drivability, although it does need a few revs to make it work.

 

Boom suspension is not an option at the moment – a potential setback for customers with large distances to travel, especially given that the P25.6 is the fastest machine out of the four.

FG Insight verdict

FG Insight verdict

As ever in group tests, each machine had its particular strengths and weaknesses highlighted by which set of engineering compromises the manufacturer took. However, on this occasion top honours go to JCB.

 

But it is so nip and tuck at the top; there is no resting on its laurels for the Stafforshire-born machine. It would only take Manitou to conjure up a bit more cab space and a bit more hydraulic performance and JCB can kiss goodbye to its top spot.

 

Similarly, with a new machine on the way from Merlo, it will definitely be a one to watch. And Dieci, yes, it is a bit of a rank outsider, but the firm seem to be on a real push at the moment in the UK and if design elements from its impressive Agri40.7 range start to filter down through its portfolio, we will have a real battle on our hands.

 

Links

Click here to see the machines in action

Twitter Facebook
Rating (0 vote/s)
Post a Comment
To see comments and join in the conversation please log in.

More Insights

NOSTALGIA: A look back at the tractor 'legends' of the 1990s

The 1990s saw a boom in the use of electronics on tractors, which in turn prompted the development of some of the most iconic tractors produced.

North Country Cheviots flourish in the Peak District

Starting a pedigree flock from scratch brings many challenges. Chloe Palmer hears about the highs and the lows of establishing the Greenhills flock of North Country Cheviots.

User story: Old school power heads up cost conscious farming fleet

With a keen eye on his bottom line, Scottish Borders farmer Richard Reed decided to exchange new machinery for tried and tested work horses.

Profit from Grass: Grazing takes precedence over grass cropping on Cumbrian farm

After a dry spring a flush of early summer grass brings its own challenges for the Stobart’s who farm near Armathwaite in Cumbria.

A passion for cow families at Erie herd

Last year’s Royal Welsh Show was a career peak for Iwan Morgan and his family’s Erie herd, taking both the inter-breed champion and reserve in the dairy ring. Laura Bowyer catches up with him at home in Carmarthenshire.
FG Insight and FGInsight.com are trademarks of Briefing Media Ltd.
Farmers Guardian and FarmersGuardian.com are trademarks of Farmers Guardian Ltd, a subsidiary of Briefing Media Ltd.
All material published on FGInsight.com and FarmersGuardian.com is copyrighted © 2016 by Briefing Media Limited. All rights reserved.
RSS news feeds